Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education · 2021 · 14 citations · 23 references
EducationInstructionTeachingInstruction In Higher EducationStudent EngagementWriting InstructionAcademic WritingClassroom FeedbackCorrective FeedbackFeedback For LearningFeedback PracticesWriting ProcessFeedback For RevisionFeedback RolesFeedback Use In LearningInstructional FeedbackSelf-regulated Behavior
In this study, a micro-level approach was used to investigate how college students in an academic writing course interact with peer and instructor feedback at different stages of the writing process. Participants were 146 first-year students at a Singaporean university. A survey and focus group interviews concerning students’ feedback-adopting strategies were conducted. Results show that, for these students, revision was a reiterative self-regulated process sustained by the different functions of both types of feedback, which were found to serve different roles at different stages. Overall, peer feedback identifies initial issues with clarity and prompts divergent thinking while, at a later stage, instructor feedback challenges ideas and encourages evaluative thinking. It is concluded that the two feedback types are complementary and should be reconceptualized to be equally valuable and indispensable. The value of feedback should be seen as a sequential structure, where both sources of feedback play essential roles at different stages, rather than a hierarchical structure, in which instructor feedback is overwhelmingly prioritized.
23
Lorelli Nowell, Jill M. Norris, Deborah White et al. · International Journal of Qualitative Methods · 2017 · 12.9K citations · Full text
Social Sciences, Health Sciences, Clinical Data Management +16
A Cognitive Process Theory of Writing
Linda Flower, John R. Hayes · College Composition and Communication · 1981 · 3.5K citations