Using Cases to Study Teaching.

Selma Wassermann

Phi Delta Kappan · 1994 · 42 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

When teacher education students read case studies, Ms. Wassermann relates, they learn that life in the classroom is not a TV sitcom, with trite and simplistic solutions dished out in neat, 30-minute packages. The Students straggle in like mournful souls from a lost weekend and find seats around the small tables. Rainy Monday-morning blahs in Education 475, Designs for learning: Mathematics. once-a-week, four-credit course for preservice teachers is in its fifth week; the students are ready to examine the issue of evaluation practices in mathematics. The plan for this four-hour session is already on the board: 8:30: Brief introduction to the session 8:35: Small-group work on case questions 10:00: Coffee break 10: 15: Whole class: debriefing the case 11:45: Analysis of the process Professor Ecks welcomes the students, comments cynically about the weather, nods in the direction of the plan, and reminds students that study groups of approximately six students are preferable. The students reach into briefcases, knapsacks, and binders and pull out the day's case, It's Up to You, Mrs. Buscemi.(1) It is assumed that the students have read the case before coming to class. Like most classroom topics, the case of Mrs. Buscemi involves several interrelated issues that bear on educational practice. Based on a real-life incident but fictionalized so that all players and circumstances remain anonymous, the case presents a situation in which a teacher is faced with the dilemma of what to do about a student who has not measured up academically in math class. Adam Wright, a minority student from an impoverished family, has been promised a scholarship to a junior college, contingent on the successful completion of his 12th-grade courses, but Mrs. Buscemi believes that Adam should fad. She has determined Adam's final grade by totaling his five test scores, his classroom participation, and his homework and then dividing the sum by seven. The average mark of 43% she has rounded off, in Adam's favor, to 45%. The principal, however, argues Adam's case. Wouldn't Mrs. Buscemi give this young man a chance for a better future by allowing him to pass? After all, Adam wasn't shirking; he is a nice boy who simply was unable, with his part-time job, his after-school preparatory classes, and his other courses, to put extra time into his math work. This would be the very first person in Adam's family who ever had a chance for higher education. How could Mrs. Buscemi deny Adam that opportunity? The questions to be examined in the study groups deal with issues of Violet Buscemi's teaching practices; her effectiveness in providing help for Adam, who was having difficulty with the material; the procedures she used in making an evaluative judgment of Adam's work; the student and his performance; and the role of the principal. Issues of affirmative action, fairness, and accuracy in evaluation practices are pivotal. The final question asks the students what they would do in Violet Buscemi's place. Twenty-six students divide themselves into five study groups and within minutes are deeply engaged with the questions. The professor observes and listens from the sidelines; she does not sit with any group, lest the discussion be more concerned with performing for her benefit than with free expression of students' ideas. However, she is far from indifferent to each group's functioning and to how each member of the group argues his or her ideas. Franklin is a strong and vocal participant in his group. He is certain that Adam's grade is just. Mitchell, another member of Franklin's group, creates a legalistic scenario in which Violet chooses to pass Adam, who then goes on to college, where he subsequently fails and sues his 12th-grade math teacher for passing him without having successfully taught him the material. In another group, Laura argues that, when she was in high school, she was hopelessly incompetent in math, but, despite her poor math grades, her teacher generously allowed her to pass. …