The Interplay between Intuition and Rationality in Strategic Decision Making: A Paradox Perspective

Giulia Calabretta, Gerda Gemser, Nachoem M. Wijnberg

Organization Studies · 2016 · 309 citations · 74 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Strategic decision making relies on both intuition and rationality, yet no framework explicitly addresses their interplay. The study aims to fill this gap by framing the intuition–rationality duality as a paradoxical tension through a paradox lens. Using seven innovation‑project case studies, the authors derive a three‑step paradoxical‑thinking process and prescribe practice sets that leverage intuitive or rational decision‑making traits at each step. Empirical data show that managing the tension begins by fostering managerial acceptance of contradictory rational and intuitive elements, then integrates both approaches to produce decision‑making outcomes, and finally embeds these outcomes into the organizational context.

Abstract

Both intuition and rationality can play important roles in strategic decision making. However, a framework that specifically accounts for the interplay between intuition and rationality is still missing. This study addresses this gap by using a paradox lens and conceptualizes the intuition–rationality duality as a paradoxical tension. We draw on seven case studies of innovation projects to empirically derive a three-step process for managing this intuition–rationality tension through paradoxical thinking. Our empirical data suggest that management of the tension starts with preparing the ground for paradoxical thinking by creating managerial acceptance for the contradictory elements of rational and intuitive approaches to decision making. The process then continues by developing decision-making outcomes through the integration of intuitive and rational practices. Finally, the outcomes of paradoxical thinking are embedded into the organizational context. For each step of the model, we indicate a set of practices that, by leveraging intuitive or rational characteristics of decision making, practitioners can use to deal with this cognitive tension in the different steps of our model.

References

74