A learning progression for scientific argumentation: Understanding student work and designing supportive instructional contexts

Leema K. Berland, Katherine L. McNeill

Science Education · 2010 · 470 citations · 53 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Argumentation is a central goal of science education, engaging students in constructing and justifying knowledge claims, yet little research has focused on developing a learning progression for this practice. The study presents a learning progression to analyze students' scientific argumentation and examines how instructional contexts influence argument complexity across elementary, middle, and high school classrooms. The progression is structured around instructional context, argumentative product, and argumentative process, and is illustrated by comparing four classroom examples across grade levels. Simplifying instructional context helps students engage more complex aspects of argumentation, can support argumentation in new content areas and enhance written argument complexity, and classroom norms are crucial for supporting students of all ages. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc., Sci Ed 94:765–793.

Abstract

Abstract Argumentation is a central goal of science education because it engages students in a complex scientific practice in which they construct and justify knowledge claims. Although there is a growing body of research around argumentation, there has been little focus on developing a learning progression for this practice. We describe a learning progression to understand both students' work in scientific argumentation and the ways in which the instructional environment can support students in that practice. This learning progression describes three dimensions: (1) instructional context, (2) argumentative product, and (3) argumentative process. In this paper, we compare four examples from elementary, middle, and high school science classrooms to explore the ways in which students' arguments vary in complexity across grade level and instructional contexts. Our comparisons suggest that simplifying the instructional context may facilitate students in engaging in other aspects of argumentation in more complex ways. The instructional context may also be used as a tool to support students in argumentation in new content areas and to increase the complexity of their written arguments, which may be weaker than their oral arguments. Furthermore, classroom norms play an important role in supporting students of all ages, including elementary students, in argumentation. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Sci Ed 94 :765–793, 2010

References

53