Distance Education · 2013 · 84 citations · 46 references
EducationEducational TechnologyTeachingE-learningOnline TeachingWriting InstructionAcademic WritingAsynchronous LearningCollaborative LearningCollaborative WritingOnline CollaborationOnline FeedbackAsynchronous WritingCollaborative Writing OnlineCollaborative Writing SupportFeedbackFeedback For Collaborative LearningOnline Collaborative WritingOnline Learning EnvironmentsStudent Writing Development
Writing research has highlighted the importance of feedback, including peer feedback, as a key support for student writing, yet empirical evidence on which feedback type best promotes writing in online environments remains scarce. The study aims to identify which type of feedback best enhances collaborative writing quality and learning outcomes in asynchronous online communication. The research compares various feedback types and sources within an asynchronous written communication environment to assess their impact. The study found that epistemic or epistemic‑and‑suggestive feedback most improves collaborative writing quality, and that teacher‑only or teacher‑and‑peer feedback only affects the final text when the feedback is epistemic or epistemic‑and‑suggestive.
The need for supporting student writing has received much attention in writing research. One specific type of support is feedback—including peer feedback—on the writing process. Despite the wealth of literature on both feedback and academic writing, there is little empirical evidence on what type of feedback best promotes writing in online environments. This article reports on research that tries to determine what type of feedback best improves the quality of collaborative writing and what the effects of feedback are on student learning in an environment based on asynchronous written communication. The results reveal that concerning the type of feedback, epistemic feedback or epistemic and suggestive feedback best improve the quality of collaborative writing performance. The nature of the feedback-giver (whether teacher feedback or teacher and peer) makes a difference to the final text only when the feedback is epistemic, or epistemic and suggestive.
46
John Hattie, Helen Timperley · Review of Educational Research · 2007 · 12.1K citations · Full text
Paul A. Kirschner, John Sweller, Richard E. Clark · Educational Psychologist · 2006 · 6.7K citations · Full text
Valerie J. Shute · Review of Educational Research · 2008 · 4.2K citations · Full text