2023 · 19 citations · 42 references
EducationInstructionScience EducationInstructional DesignReading ComprehensionReading DevelopmentAdaptive LearningCritical ComprehensionCritical ReadingCritical ThinkingReadingReading InstructionAdaptive Reading SupportAdaptive Reading SystemsCritical Thinking InstructionMain Idea InstructionQuestioning For Critical ThinkingSummarization For LearningUser Requirements AnalysisUser Requirements Specification
Learning to read scientific papers critically, which requires first grasping their main ideas and then raising critical thoughts, is important yet challenging for novice researchers. The traditional ways to develop critical paper reading (CPR) skills, e.g., checking general tutorials or taking reading courses, often can not provide individuals with adaptive and accessible support. In this paper, we first derive user requirements of a CPR training tool based on literature and a survey study (N=52). Then, we develop CriTrainer , an interactive tool for CPR training. It leverages text summarization techniques to train readers’ skills in grasping the paper’s main ideas. It further utilizes template-based generated questions to help them learn how to raise critical thoughts. A mixed-design study (N=24) shows that compared to a baseline tool with general CPR guidance, students trained by CriTrainer perform better in independently raising critical thinking questions on a new paper. We conclude with design considerations for CPR training tools.
42
Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience
Richard Buchanan, Mihály Csíkszentmihályi · Design Issues · 1991 · 9.5K citations
Eshwar Chandrasekharan, Umashanthi Pavalanathan, Anirudh Srinivasan et al. · Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction · 2017 · 374 citations
Critical thinking: seven definitions in search of a concept
Tim Moore · Studies in Higher Education · 2011 · 318 citations · Full text