Doing Less Work, Collecting Better Data: Using Capstone Courses to Assess Learning

Catherine White Berheide

2007 · 42 citations · 9 references

Concepts

Abstract

I have never met a faculty member who was excited about doing assessment, although rumor has it they exist. In fact, most have been resistant if not downright hostile to the notion. I fall in the resistant category. I have too much work to do to welcome any new task. Surprisingly, the wrong reason-minimizing the additional work-has lead to the right way to do program assessment. Analyzing work students produce in the capstone is simply easier than most other assessment options. Fortunately, it also provides better measures of student learning. Since I am not the only faculty member to have come to this conclusion, capstones are becoming central components of assessment plans. Using Capstones to Assess Undergraduate Education The capstone course provides a venue for assessing how successfully the major has attained the overall (Wagenaar 1993, 214). Indeed, according to Rowles et al. (2004), assessment is the primary organizing principle of capstones. As Black and Hundley note, when students look back on their four years of college in a capstone course, they invaluable information to faculty about the quality of instruction and of (2004, 3). Many programs are taking advantage of this rich source of data (Berheide 2001; Brock 2004; Forest and Keith 2004). National surveys of departments reveal that in political science as well as in sociology, capstones are the most common assessment (Kelly and Klunk 2003; Spalter-Roth and Erskine 2003). Henscheid (2000) finds that almost half of 707 regionally accredited colleges and universities use capstones as part of their institution s assessment program. While Henscheid also finds that smaller colleges and universities are more likely to use capstones for assessment than larger ones, at the University of Washington, about 60 percent of the departments use some kind of senior experience-including capstone courses, design courses, and senior seminars-to evaluate students learning in the (Beyer 2001, 1). At Valdosta State University, nineteen of twenty-four academic units evaluate performance in capstone courses as a method of assessment, making it the third most frequently used method behind final exams and evaluation of course presentations (Yates 2004). Similarly, at Seton Hall, twenty-two out of thirty-three academic units use capstone courses as part of their assessment programs. Across disciplines, private institutions are more likely than public ones to use products from capstone courses to assess undergraduate education. Assessing Capstone Products Currently departments use capstone products to assess their majors in a variety of ways, ranging from rudimentary to rigorous. Beginning at the most basic level, departments require students to publicly present their work as an exhibition, performance, poster, etc. (Bachand et al. 2006, 21). These displays the most direct and most unfiltered picture of students' capabilities (Hartmann 1992, 128). When these presentations are judged in way, the assessment process has moved to the next stage. For example, institutions-including Saginaw Valley State University and Skidmore College, where I teach-submit projects for presentation at conferences or to undergraduate paper contests, providing external validation of the quality of student work. Some programs, including the engineering programs at Saginaw Valley State University, even use external evaluators to grade the projects. Best practice, though, involves going a step further to analyze the projects systematically for the evidence they provide about program quality and to use that evidence to make curricular improvements. For example, the sociology department at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee uses five Likert scale items to assess how well the capstone papers demonstrate achievement of the department's learning goals (2006). A more elaborate approach involves applying an existing rubric, such as Primary Trait Analysis (Jervis and Hartley 2005), or a locally developed one (Cappell and Kamens 2002) to capstone products. …

References

9