The Consequenc.es of Increasing the Number of Terms Used to Score Open-ended Concept Maps

Roy B. Clariana, Ellen Taricani

International journal of instructional media · 2010 · 27 citations · 7 references

Concepts

Abstract

This descriptive study considers the consequence of increasing the number of terms used when scoring open-ended concept maps. Participants (n=24) read an instructional text and drew concept maps of the content, then completed a multiple-choice posttest that measured vocabulary and comprehension. The distances between terms in each participant's concept map were transformed into three proximity arrays using the 16, 26, and 36 most important terms from an expert's map. A Pathfinder Network analysis approach was used to analyze the distance proximity array data. The concept map scores derived using the 16 most important terms were all significantly related to the multiple-choice posttest scores, with Common scores based on term spatial location being most related to comprehension (r=0.57) and Terms scores based on the number of important terms included on the map being most related to vocabulary (r=0.55). However, contrary to expectation, increasing the number of terms used to score the maps did not increase the predictive ability of the map scores, probably due to students not selecting enough of the most important words to include in their maps. Recalling important terms to include in a map appears to be an important and discrete cognitive task. Cautions and implications are provided.

References

7