The Elementary School Journal · 1989 · 20 citations · 9 references
EducationEducational AssessmentEducational MeasurementPsychometricsSummative AssessmentWriting InstructionAnalytic ScoringHolistic ScoringTeacher EvaluationWriting AssessmentWriting DevelopmentWriting SkillsDescriptive Writing AssessmentHolistic Essay ScoringPunctuation In Sentence StructureWriting AchievementWriting Development MeasurementWriting Quality Assessment
The concurrent validity of holistic scores for writing quality, as determined by Tiedt's (1983) holistic-scoring criteria, and of constructs of teachers' analytic scores, as determined by Diederich's (1974) analytic evaluation procedure, was examined. Following training in these 2 writing-evaluation procedures, 4 classroom teachers' holistic scores of writing samples produced by 4 low-ability male eighth graders were highly correlated with their analytic scores for the same samples. However, a regression of the analytic-scoring features on the holistic scores determined that "quality and development of ideas" was the only analytic feature that accounted for a significant amount of the variance in holistic scores for all teachers. The amount of variance attributed to writing features other than ideas, organization, style, wording/phrasing, grammar/sentence structure, punctuation, and spelling ranged from 28% to 61% for the 4 teachers.
9