Journal of Educational Psychology · 1979 · 100 citations · 13 references
EducationEducational PsychologyTeachingClassroom AssessmentPedagogyWriting InstructionAcademic WritingEssay WritingFormative EvaluationStudent ReflectionTeacher EvaluationWriting AssessmentAcademic Writing AssessmentFormative Teacher EvaluationStudent Evaluation Of Teaching
This article explores the question of why competent evaluators award the ratings they do to college students' expository essays. Essays were rewritten to be stronger or weaker in four categories: content, organization, sentence structure, and mechanics. Twelve evaluators first used a 4-point holistic rating scale to judge the essays' quality. Then they rated whether each of the four rewriting categories in each rewritten essay was strong or weak (perceptions). Analyses of variance revealed content and organization to affect ratings most (p < .001). Mechanics and sentence structure had smaller effects, which differed when measured by the actual rewriting versus by the perceptions. Mechanics and sentence structure were significant in their interaction with organization (p < .001 andp < .01, respectively).
13
Essentials of Psychological Testing
Benjamin Rosner, Lee J. Cronbach · The American Journal of Psychology · 1960 · 4.6K citations
John S. Mayher, Peter Elbow · The English Journal · 1975 · 1.2K citations
Education, Instruction, Teaching +15
Rhetoric: Discovery and Change
Regina M. Hoover, Richard E. Young, Alton Becker et al. · College Composition and Communication · 1971 · 274 citations