Deconstructing the value proposition of an innovation exemplar

Adrian Payne, Pennie Frow

European Journal of Marketing · 2014 · 54 citations · 67 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Value‑proposition research has become a key priority for the Marketing Science Institute. The study seeks to develop a deconstruction process that clarifies the elements of superior value offerings and shows how it can be applied by other organizations to improve their competitive position. Using a case study of a health‑care exemplar and a business‑system framework, the authors identify key value‑adding elements and demonstrate the approach with a leading financial‑services firm. The authors present a structured, recursive framework that incorporates value‑in‑use and learning processes, offering practitioners actionable guidance for formulating new or improved value propositions.

Abstract

Purpose – Research into the identification and development of value propositions has recently been identified as a key research priority by the Marketing Science Institute. The purpose of this article is to identify and develop a process for value proposition deconstruction that can help organizations transform their value propositions in order to gain an improvement in their competitive position. Design/methodology/approach – A case study of an exemplar organization in the health care sector is used to develop an approach for value proposition deconstruction. Using the business system concept as a theoretical framework, the key value-adding elements that comprise this organization's value proposition are identified. A leading financial services firm is used to demonstrate how this learning approach can be successfully applied in developing a new and innovative value proposition. Findings – Using the business system framework, a structured process for deconstructing value propositions is developed. This framework is extended to explicitly acknowledge the value-in-use that results from different encounters, to incorporate learning processes and to recognize its interactive and recursive nature. Practical implications – The authors provide practitioners with insight into how to formulate new or improved value propositions. Originality/value – This work addresses two important and previously unaddressed research questions: how can the process of deconstruction of an exemplar organization's value proposition provide a more comprehensive understanding of the elements that comprise a superior value offering; and how can this process be applied to other organizations seeking to improve their value proposition?

References

67