Volunteer Tutoring Programs: Do We Know What Works?.

Barbara A. Wasik

Phi Delta Kappan · 1997 · 39 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Ms. Wasik reviews the current state of knowledge about the effects on achievement of various tutoring programs that use adult volunteers. If the America Reads Challenge is to attain its ambitious goals, it is essential that its tutoring programs be founded on a solid base of research, she points out. The America Reads Challenge of the Clinton Administration makes a national commitment to the goal that every child will read independently and well by the end of third grade. This is a goal of great importance; 40% of all U.S. children are now reading below the basic level on national reading assessments. The President's challenge has focused attention on the importance of reading and education in children's lives. Children who do not learn to read in the early grades begin life's journey on a path of failure and poverty. The primary component of the America Reads Challenge is the use of adult volunteers to tutor children during and after school and on weekends. As many as one million tutors will be working with children to help them learn to read. An estimated $2.75 billion is proposed to be invested in this initiative. This is an ambitious and important program that has great potential, but there are several issues regarding volunteers and the roles that they will play in schools that must be carefully considered if this program is to have an impact on the reading performance of young children. The crucial issue, which has yet to be systematically addressed, is how these volunteers can be used most effectively by the schools. All over America, school administrators, principals, and community activists are scrambling to identify or develop volunteer tutoring programs for their schools. Unfortunately, there are few guidelines for doing so. Before millions of volunteers enter our schools, it is important to analyze carefully the roles they can play and the kinds of training they will need to be effective. There are literally hundreds of grassroots tutoring programs that are being used in the schools. Some have training for tutors that is very well developed; others do not. Some programs have written materials for tutors to follow; others rely mostly on the oral dissemination of information. Some have student materials; most do not. In addition, because many of these programs were developed to fulfill a specific need in a particular school, little attention has been paid to evaluating or disseminating the programs. Thus many programs are now being implemented across school districts with little evidence of their effectiveness. The most important question about any new program in education is, Do we know what works? My purpose here is to review the current state of knowledge about the effects on achievement of various tutoring programs that use adult volunteers. If the America Reads Challenge is to attain its ambitious goals, it is essential that its tutoring programs be founded on a solid base of research. Research on Tutoring Currently, there is very little work documenting the effectiveness of using volunteers as tutors. A meta-analysis on cross-age and peer tutoring found positive achievement effects for tutoring.(1) However, the researchers included all tutoring studies regardless of subject area, level of tutor training, and amount of time spent tutoring, so it is difficult to separate out the true effects of peer tutoring programs on early reading. None of the programs used adult community volunteers or college students. Robert Slavin and I reviewed five tutoring programs that used certified teachers and paraprofessionals.(2) The findings from this review document two important conclusions. First, one-to-one tutoring is an extremely effective form of instruction, the primary drawback being the high cost. Second, programs that used certified teachers as tutors appeared to have substantially larger effects than those that used paraprofessionals. Furthermore, in the programs that used paraprofessionals effectively to help children learn to read, the paraprofessionals were highly trained, and the program was highly structured, with specific tutors' manuals, student materials, and training procedures. …