CBE—Life Sciences Education · 2022 · 15 citations · 27 references
EducationEducational AssessmentTeachingAssessment DesignFormative AssessmentStem EducationEvaluation PlanningFormative EvaluationOutcome EvaluationStem AssessmentSummative EvaluationTeacher EvaluationDepartmental LeadershipDepartmental TargetsIterative Design DevelopmentIterative Design ProcessIterative Development ModelMathematics Program EvaluationStem Program EvaluationStudent Evaluation Of Teaching
Most science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) departments inadequately evaluate teaching, which means they are not equipped to recognize or reward effective teaching. As part of a project at one institution, we observed that departmental chairs needed help recognizing the decisions they would need to make to improve teaching evaluation practices. To meet this need, we developed the Guides to Advance Teaching Evaluation (GATEs), using an iterative development process. The GATEs are designed to be a planning tool that outlines concrete goals to guide reform in teaching evaluation practices in STEM departments at research-intensive institutions. The GATEs are grounded in the available scholarly literature and guided by existing reform efforts and have been vetted with STEM departmental chairs. The GATEs steer departments to draw on three voices to evaluate teaching: trained peers, students, and the instructor. This research-based resource includes three components for each voice: 1) a list of departmental target practices to serve as goals; 2) a characterization of common starting places to prompt reflection; and 3) ideas for getting started. We provide anecdotal examples of potential uses of the GATEs for reform efforts in STEM departments and as a research tool to document departmental practices at different time points.
27
Increased Structure and Active Learning Reduce the Achievement Gap in Introductory Biology
David C. Haak, Janneke HilleRisLambers, Emile Pitre et al. · Science · 2011 · 962 citations
Education, Biology, Instruction +15
Anatomy of STEM teaching in North American universities
Marilyne Stains, Jordan Harshman, Matthew Barker et al. · Science · 2018 · 762 citations · Full text