Rubric development for assessment of undergraduate research: Evaluating multidisciplinary team projects

James A. Newell, Heidi L. Newell, Kevin Dahm

2004 · 25 citations · 19 references

Concepts

Abstract

At Rowan University, all engineering students participate in clinic courses involving multidisciplinary student teams working on semester-long or year-long research projects led by an engineering professor. The difficulty arises in trying to assess student learning and performance in project-based team settings. Faced with the complexity of tryi ng to assess the attainment o f learning outcomes for each individual on a team based on an unclear blend of technical merit, communication, project planning, data analysis, and teaming behaviors, faculty members and students both fall short. It is unreasonable to expect students to a chieve specific learning objectives from a series of courses, when the faculty members themselves are unclear about what the learning objectives are and how to measure them As a first effort to address the assessment of team performance in project-based research experiences, the faculty of the Chemical Engineering Department, as a pilot study, developed four primary areas of importance for assessment. Once these areas were selected, specific indicators were developed for each, so that the students would have clearly defined goals and behaviors that reflect the desired learning outcomes. Faculty assessment of these rubrics indicate that they are very effective in demystifying the evaluation process and serve to better connect the grade in the course to the stated learning objectives.

References

19