The Reading Teacher · 1978 · 10 citations · 1 references
EducationInstructionLiteracy EducationReading ComprehensionReading DevelopmentReading EducationEarly Literacy SkillsError AnalysisReadingReading AccuracyReading AssessmentReading DifficultiesAssessment Error AnalysisCount Error AnalysisOral Reading ErrorsOral Reading PracticeReading Error PatternsReading Miscue AnalysisReading MiscuesText Reading Accuracy
46T MAY BE old-fashioned, but I X think today's experts compli cate things too much. I remember when oral reading errors were errors, not miscues, and when error analysis was so easy first graders could do it. We taught a child to read the first page of a book and put up one finger for each unknown word. If all the fingers on one hand went up before the page was finished, this showed the book was too hard for that child to read. Maybe the method for first grad ers was a little oversimplified. But do you really believe a teacher who has 25 or more pupils will use modern day miscue analysis if it takes much more time than that? Does a teacher really need to know more than the total number of errors made in proportion to the number of words that were read? As obtained in the traditional informal reading inven tory (IRI), this information requires little more than first grade math skills except to count past 100 and know how to divide. In less than 30 minutes a teacher can determine a child's oral reading accuracy level and place the child in appropriate instructional materials. What else could be learned that's worth taking more time? With comments such as these, a veteran teacher of reading might question whether miscue analysis is really an essential diagnostic tool. It certainly takes a great deal more time than the traditional IRI. The miscue analysis procedure, as originally de signed for use in descriptive research, required about 15 hours per child (K. Goodman 1973). It was recommend ed as much more helpful to teachers than simply counting errors (Y. Goodman 1972), but even in its adaptation to classroom use it still requires a lot of time (Y. Goodman
1