The Journal of Experimental Education · 2009 · 110 citations · 61 references
EducationInstructionTeachingClassroom AssessmentFormative AssessmentRhetoricArgument ComprehensionArgument StructureArgumentationArgumentation TheoryFeedback For LearningFeedback In AssessmentArgument EffectivenessArgument Quality AssessmentArgumentation AnalysisArgumentation StructureCritical Evaluation Of ArgumentsStructural Quality AssessmentStudent Argumentation
Evaluating the structural quality of arguments is a skill important to students' ability to comprehend the arguments of others and produce their own. The authors examined college and high school students' ability to evaluate the quality of 2-clause (claim-reason) arguments and tested a tutorial to improve this ability. These experiments indicated that college and high school students had difficulty evaluating arguments on the basis of their quality. Experiments 1 and 2 showed that a tutorial explaining skills important to overall argument evaluation increased performance but that immediate feedback during training was necessary for teaching students to evaluate the claim-reason connection. Using a Web-based version of the tutorial, Experiment 3 extended this finding to the performance of high-school students. The study suggests that teaching the structure of an argument and teaching students to pay attention to the precise message of the claim can improve argument evaluation.
61
Toward a model of text comprehension and production.
Walter Kintsch, Teun A. van Dijk · Psychological Review · 1978 · 5K citations
Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data
M. Venkatesan, K. Anders Ericsson, Herbert A. Simon · Journal of Marketing Research · 1986 · 4.4K citations