Learning Mathematics From Examples and by Doing

Xinming Zhu, Herbert A. Simon

Cognition and Instruction · 1987 · 346 citations · 9 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The article demonstrates that math skills can be taught effectively through carefully selected sequences of worked examples and problems, eliminating the need for lectures or direct instruction. The authors analyze thinking‑aloud protocols from 20 students learning factorization via this example‑based method to assess the depth and nature of their understanding. Students applied procedures appropriately, used conceptual understanding to guide learning and verification, and the method successfully covered a full three‑year algebra and geometry curriculum in a Chinese middle school.

Abstract

This article demonstrates the feasibility and effectiveness of teaching several mathematical skills by presenting students with carefully chosen sequences of worked-out examples and problems - without lectures or other direct instruction. Thinking-aloud protocols of 20 students learning factorization by this method are analyzed to determine the kinds and depth of understanding students attained. Students did not simply memorize procedures but were able to recognize when the procedures were applicable and to apply them. Most students were also able to use their understanding of the concept of factorization to help learn the procedures and to check their results. The method of learning from examples has now been tested successfully with a class covering the entire 3-year curriculum in algebra and geometry in a Chinese middle school.

References

9