The Use of Worked Examples as a Substitute for Problem Solving in Learning Algebra

TLDR

The study hypothesizes that algebra problem‑solving depends on many schemas, and that conventional problem‑solving delays schema acquisition. Five experiments investigated the knowledge required for algebra manipulation and evaluated worked examples as a strategy to accelerate schema acquisition. Results indicate that experienced students better represent equations, worked examples reduce solution time and errors, but the gains are confined to structurally identical problems, suggesting novices need extensive practice to generalize rules.

Abstract

The knowledge required to solve algebra manipulation problems and procedures designed to hasten knowledge acquisition were studied in a series of five experiments. It was hypothesized that, as occurs in other domains, algebra problem-solving skill requires a large number of schemas and that schema acquisition is retarded by conventional problem-solving search techniques. Experiment 1, using Year 9, Year 11, and university mathematics students, found that the more experienced students had a better cognitive representation of algebraic equations than less experienced students as measured by their ability to (a) recall equations, and (b) distinguish between perceptually similar equations on the basis of solution mode. Experiments 2 through 5 studied the use of worked examples as a means of facilitating the acquisition of knowledge needed for effective problem solving. It was found that not only did worked examples, as expected, require considerably less time to process than conventional problems, but that subsequent problems similar to the initial ones also were solved more rapidly. Furthermore, decreased solution time was accompanied by a decrease in the number of mathematical errors. Both of these findings were specific to problems identical in structure to the initial ones. It was concluded that for novice problem solvers, general algebra rules are reflected in only a limited number of schemas. Abstraction of general rules from schemas may occur only with considerable practice and exposure to a wider range of schemas.