Decomposing Influence Strategies: Argument Structure and Dependence as Determinants of the Effectiveness of Influence Strategies in Gaining Channel Member Compliance

Janice M. Payan, Richard G. McFarland

Journal of Marketing · 2005 · 251 citations · 50 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Research on influence strategies has focused on relational outcomes, but their effectiveness in securing channel member compliance remains unexplored. The study develops a theoretical model predicting that noncoercive influence strategies with thorough argument structures increase compliance, while coercive strategies succeed only when target dependence is high, and introduces a new Rationality strategy. The authors construct a theoretical framework and propose the Rationality strategy, a noncoercive approach featuring a complete argument structure. Empirical results largely support the model, yet Recommendations unexpectedly reduce compliance, especially when trust is low, revealing a trust–recommendation interaction.

Abstract

Although there is considerable research examining the effects of influence strategies on relational outcomes, research has been silent on the effectiveness of influence strategies in achieving the primary objective: channel member compliance. The authors develop a theoretical model that predicts that noncoercive influence strategies (Rationality, Recommendations, Information Exchange, and Requests) with an argument structure that contains more thorough content result in relatively greater levels of compliance. The model further predicts that coercive influence strategies (Promises and Threats) result in compliance only when target dependence levels are high. The authors develop a new influence strategy, Rationality, which represents a noncoercive strategy with a full argument structure. In general, empirical findings support the theoretical model. However, in contrast to expectations, the use of Recommendations had a negative effect on compliance. Post hoc analysis revealed a significant interaction between trust and Recommendations on compliance, thus providing an explanation for this unexpected result. When trust is low, Recommendation strategies are counterproductive. The authors discuss implications of the findings and directions for further research.

References

50