Journal of managerial issues · 2007 · 15 citations · 26 references
ManagementOrganizational BehaviorBusiness EthicsCorporate Social ResponsibilityEthicsEthical Business PracticesOrganizational EthicsReputationReputation ManagementCorporate Reputation EffectsCorporate Reputation HarmCorporate Social Responsibility ValuesCorporate Social Responsibility ViolationsDeceptive DisclosuresEthical Decision-making In CorporationsMoral Responsibility JudgmentsShareholder Value Management
Recent large-scale corporate scandals have turned business ethics and corporate moral responsibility into a major concern of managers, business schools, and the general public. Companies such as Tyco International, Ltd., Adelphia Communications, MCI (formerly Worldcom) and Enron have experienced significant damage to their reputations due to the malfeasance of high-level corporate executives. Results from the 2004 Harris-Fombrun Reputation Quotient survey listed Enron and MCI as having the worst reputations from the list of the 60 most visible companies rated in America (Reputation Management, 2005). Tyco and Adelphia were also ranked among the ten worst companies. The fraudulent and deceptive practices of these and other corporations, once again, have researchers seeking an answer to the question of what influences managers' decisions in moral and ethical so that they may offer some insights to the business community on how to prepare future executives and managers to face challenges and the public's increasing expectation of corporate moral responsibility. Unfortunately, empirical research in business ethics and social responsibility has been limited (e.g., Donaldson, 2003). Extant empirical studies in this research area have focused mainly on measuring and comparing the attitudes and ethical beliefs of managers, entrepreneurs, employees at different organizational levels, business students and academic faculty, and the results have been somewhat inconclusive (e.g., Bucar and Hisrich, 2001). Those studies have merits in their own right. However, they may not directly fulfill the need of the business community to understand the driving forces that may influence corporate conduct, especially in the face of moral dilemmas, by managers whose decisions may have broad-scale consequences to multiple stakeholders such as shareholders, suppliers, employees, customers, the business community, society and, potentially, the economy as a whole. To help fill the research gap, this study identifies two potential factors that may play a major role in managers' decision making when they face moral dilemmas. They are the ideology of shareholder value and the norm of reciprocity. The ideology of shareholder value is the belief that managers have a duty to maximize profits and shareholders' wealth, while the norm of reciprocity is the social norm that business should play its part in supporting stakeholders since stakeholders play a major role in supporting business (i.e., reciprocal relationships between business and stakeholders). This study aims to answer the following research question: How do the ideology of shareholder value and the norm of reciprocity influence managerial decision making in stakeholder moral dilemmas with suppliers, customers and employees? BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY Ethical decision making literature has evolved around two major themes: 1) ethical perceptions and attitudes and 2) social responsibilities of business. The research stream in ethical perceptions and attitudes operates at a micro level by attempting to unveil behaviors or actions that individuals in the business community perceive as ethical or unethical. The main thesis of this research stream is that cultural, organizational and individual differences influence individuals' ethical attitudes and perceptions. Prior research has found that the national origin of business students has an impact on their reactions to ethical dilemmas involving employees, supervisors, customers, suppliers, and business rivals (e.g., Nyaw and Ng, 1994), and that cultural dimensions (e.g., power distance, individualism) were significantly related to ethical attitudes toward business practices (e.g., Hood and Logsdon, 2002; Volkema, 2004). Ethical perceptions, values and judgments were also found to significantly differ by organizational functionalities such as marketing and research (Hunt et al., 1989), by hierarchical levels and the length of tenure with the organization (Harris, 1990), by work group characteristics (Jennings et al. …
26
The Practice of Social Research
Alan Neustadtl, Earl R. Babbie · Teaching Sociology · 1989 · 14.5K citations
The Norm of Reciprocity: A Preliminary Statement
Alvin W. Gouldner · American Sociological Review · 1960 · 11.8K citations
The Use of Vignettes in Survey Research
Cheryl Alexander, Henry Jay Becker · Public Opinion Quarterly · 1978 · 1.2K citations