American Educational Research Journal · 2016 · 38 citations · 51 references
EducationEducational AssessmentEducational MeasurementClassroom AssessmentClassroom ManagementEducational Policy ComparisonClassroom Assessment PracticesStudent Achievement AnalysisTeacher EvaluationTeacher Evaluation ReformTeacher Labor MarketsTeacher Effectiveness EvaluationTeacher Evaluation SystemsTeacher Evaluation Using Test ScoresTeacher Labor Market SortingTeacher Quality ImprovementTeacher Quality IndicatorsTeacher Quality MetricsValue-added Teacher Evaluation
Education agencies are evaluating teachers using student achievement data. However, very little is known about the comparability of test-based or “value-added” metrics across districts and the extent to which they capture variability in classroom practices. Drawing on data from four urban districts, we found that teachers were categorized differently when compared within versus across districts. In addition, analyses of scores from two observation instruments, as well as qualitative viewing of lesson videos, identified stark differences in instructional practices across districts among teachers who received similar within-district value-added rankings. These patterns were not explained by observable background characteristics of teachers, suggesting that factors beyond labor market sorting likely played a key role.
51