Sociology of Education · 2004 · 530 citations · 26 references
Social SciencesEducational PsychologySocial PsychologyDiscriminationPrejudiceStereotypingEducational DiscriminationRace DiscriminationRace In EducationRace In SchoolingRacial DiscriminationRacismBias In Teacher EvaluationClassroom Behavior AnalysisClassroom Social BehaviorMatchingOppositional Culture TheoryRacial Bias In TeachingTeacher FairnessTeacher Judgment Bias
Past studies show black students receive more favorable classroom behavior ratings from black teachers than from white teachers, a pattern that may reflect white teacher bias or black student misbehavior. The study tests whether mismatched race effects are stronger among adolescents than young children, as would be expected if misbehavior explanations are correct. Matching effects were estimated using data from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study—Kindergarten Class of 1998‑99 and the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988. The analysis revealed comparable matching effects for kindergartners and eighth graders, supporting the white teacher bias hypothesis over oppositional culture.
Past studies have noted that black students' classroom behavior is rated more favorably by black teachers than by white teachers. This pattern could be a function of white teachers' bias—rating black students more harshly than they deserve—or black students' misbehavior—acting out more when placed with white teachers versus black teachers. If explanations emphasizing black students' misbehavior (oppositional culture) are accurate, matching effects should be more substantial among adolescents than among young children. To assess this possibility, the authors estimated matching effects among kindergartners in the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study—Kindergarten Class of 1998-99 and eighth graders from the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988. They found that the effects of matching are comparable across both kindergartners and adolescents, a pattern that is more readily understood from the position of white teachers' bias than from that of oppositional culture.
26