Deep time framework: A preliminary study of U.K. primary teachers' conceptions of geological time and perceptions of geoscience

Roger Trend

Journal of Research in Science Teaching · 2001 · 134 citations · 18 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study examined 51 in‑service teachers of 7‑ to 11‑year‑old children to explore their orientations toward geoscience phenomena and deep time. The research aimed to identify teachers’ idiosyncratic conceptions of deep time and to propose a curricular Deep Time Framework for constructivist teacher training. The authors investigated teachers’ perceptions, conceptions of deep time, and teaching approaches by posing three research questions on geoscience phenomena, deep‑time cognition, and curriculum integration of history and geology. Results identified 20 geoscience phenomena that align with teachers’ interests and classroom encounters, revealed that teachers cluster geo‑events into three temporal categories with little consensus on exact timing, and showed that teachers are more imaginative in teaching history than geology and view deep time and past environments as of limited significance in interpreting geological specimens. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Abstract

As part of a continuing research program on the understanding of geological time (deep time) across society, a total of 51 in-service teachers of 7- to 11-year-old children was studied in relation to their orientations toward geoscience phenomena in general and deep time in particular. The first purpose of the research was to identify the nature of idiosyncratic conceptions of deep time: a cognitive deep time framework of pivotal geo-events. The second was to propose a curricular Deep Time Framework that may form the basis for constructivist approaches to in-service and pre-service teacher training which places deep time center stage. Three research questions were posed, addressing: (1) perceptions of geoscience phenomena and teachers' actual encounters with these in the classroom; (2) conceptions of deep time; and (3) approaches to teaching two curriculum areas (history and geology) which involve the interpretation of material evidence to reconstruct the past. Results enable the selection of 20 geoscience phenomena to be located in relation to teachers' interests and classroom encounters, those of high interest and high encounters being proposed as pivotal areas for further attention in teacher training. Results also reveal that in-service teachers conceive events in the geological past (geo-events) as having occurred in three distinct clusters: extremely ancient; moderately ancient; and less ancient. Within each category there is a strong lack of consensus on time-of-occurrence. Results suggest that primary teachers exhibit greater imagination in their teaching of history compared with geology and that aspects of deep time and past environments are not perceived as being of any great significance in the interpretation of geological specimens. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 38: 191–221, 2001

References

18