Problem‐based learning using a human patient simulator

Ian Winston, John L. Szarek

Medical Education · 2005 · 14 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Context and setting Our simulator problem-based learning (PBL) programme was directed towards fourth semester students at Ross University School of Medicine as part of our systems-based curriculum. Why the idea was necessary The original design of our PBL programme called for weekly sessions that were held concurrently with the basic science courses, but only in the first 3 semesters. This alone provided the main impetus for change: we wanted to incorporate a PBL component into the fourth semester. Our fourth semester curriculum integrates an introduction to clinical medicine, microbiology, pathology and pharmacology, based on organ systems. Thus we wanted to develop a PBL programme that would enhance the students' experience in the integrated curriculum and begin preparing them for their first clinical rotation. What was done We reasoned that, in order to achieve these goals, we would need to have the students encounter a problem in a lifelike situation. Therefore, we purchased a human patient simulator (HPS Version 6; Medical Education Technologies, Inc., Sarasota, Florida, USA) and set it up in a laboratory that resembled a clinical examination room. The simulator PBL sessions were conducted in a manner that paralleled with that used in the first 3 semesters, except for 2 main differences. Firstly, the students (in groups of 10–12) encountered the problem in 3 sessions over a 2–3-day period instead of over a 2-week period. The human patient simulator has many attributes of human anatomy and physiology. There is a speaker in the manikin's head that allows it to talk by means of an actor speaking into a wireless microphone. Thus, the second difference reflected the manner in which the students acquired the data. Instead of progressive disclosure of the case on paper, they generated the data using their communication and physical examination skills. At the end of the case the students were asked to complete a questionnaire designed to gauge their response to the sessions. Evaluation of results and impact A total of 136 students completed the questionnaires. The students were nearly unanimous in agreeing that the sessions helped to enhance their understanding in the area of the case. Similarly, 99% of the students thought the sessions were useful. When asked to provide reasons, the comments could be grouped into 1 of 3 themes: the sessions helped to integrate the courses in the fourth semester (38% of the written comments); the sessions challenged the students to apply their knowledge (21%), and the sessions helped students identify gaps in their knowledge (11%). Pertaining to how the sessions could be improved, the most frequent comments were those suggesting more cases (38%) and smaller group sizes (7%). The impact of the programme to date can be summed up by a student who commented: ‘I found the experience useful because it allowed the integration of material in a clinical setting. It also served as a first introduction to how we will be expected to act and think once we get to the hospital.’