Dealing with the uncertainties of environmental change by adding scenario planning to the strategy reformulation equation

Philip R. Walsh

Management Decision · 2005 · 119 citations · 24 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Assessing environmental change reveals unique shifts, their strategic implications, and the need for specialized techniques such as scenario planning, while studies must also consider business scope and resource commitments. The paper argues that integrating scenario planning with traditional strategy methods helps firms navigate uncertainty and evolutionary environmental change. The authors review literature on traditional and scenario-based strategy construction and employ a reformulation equation to model possible environments and analyze strategic implications of different scenarios. Combining PESTEL analysis, internal resource assessment, and scenario planning yields a clearer understanding of firm performance in changing environments, demonstrating that this integrated approach uniquely equips managers to formulate and implement strategies that sustain competitive advantage.

Abstract

Purpose This paper serves to discuss the benefit of applying scenario‐planning techniques to more traditional approaches to strategy development in helping firms deal with uncertainty and evolutionary change in their surrounding environment. Assessing this environment provides insight into the unique changes, the implications these changes have on a firm's strategies, and the creation of special techniques required to understand them. One of these special techniques is scenario planning. Any study of the relationship between strategy, environment and performance must include variables that involve business scope and resource commitments. Design/methodology/approach A review of the research literature on the use and benefits of both the traditional approaches and the scenario approach to constructing the future strategy of a firm in a changing environment is undertaken. Findings The results suggest that a better understanding of the performance of firms within a changed environment can be achieved using the combination of a PESTEL analysis, internal resource analysis and the use of scenarios. This reformulation equation creates a model of a possible environment in which the firm must operate and an investigation of the strategic implications of various scenarios to the firm. Originality/value This paper is unique in that it marries the traditional approaches to strategy development with the application of scenario planning. It is of benefit to managers and strategic planners by illustrating how a firm may better develop insight into how it should formulate and implement its strategy in order to retain or create a competitive advantage in the changed environment in which it operates.

References

24