Readers' comprehension and strategies in linear text and hypertext

Peter W. Foltz

1993 · 24 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Hypertexts present methods to read online texts that are different from those available when reading standard linear texts. Hypertexts give readers more flexibility in choosing paths through the text and in finding relevant information. However, research in hypertext has often shown little or no advantages over the equivalent linear text. This research applied text comprehension theory to make comparisons of the readers' comprehension and strategies in linear text and hypertext. The theory hypothesized that hypertext would break down the coherence of the text, adversely affecting the readers' comprehension. To test this hypothesis, two experiments were run. In the first experiment, subjects read a textbook chapter in one of three text formats: linear text, hypertext, or coherent hypertext. Subjects reading goals were manipulated so that half looked for specific information while the other half read for general knowledge. Although the reading goals affected what subjects looked for in the text, comprehension was equivalent for the three text formats. An analysis of the subjects' reading strategies indicated that despite the different text formats, subjects used a similar reading strategy. Subjects tried to maintain a coherent path through the text, which resulted in subjects seeing a similar coherent representation of the text. The second experiment examined the strategies used in the hypertext format. Verbal protocols of the subjects indicated that they used reading heuristics and signals in the text to guide them through the text in a coherent manner. Even when subjects jumped to different places to find specific information, they still made these jumps coherently. The results of both experiments provide evidence for the dominance of maintaining global coherence in a text. Subjects presented with opportunities of reading a hypertext non-coherently, nevertheless chose to use strategies to maintain a coherent macrostructure of the text. These results suggest areas of improvement for models of hypertext readers' comprehension and strategies and implications for the design of successful online text systems.