A Comparison of Approaches to Importance-Performance Analysis

Donald R. Bacon

International Journal of Market Research · 2003 · 421 citations · 22 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Several different approaches have been used to undertake Importance‑Performance Analysis (IPA), also known as quadrant or gap analysis. The study aims to identify the most valid method for performing IPA and to provide a method for confirming its validity. The authors compare multiple IPA approaches across 15 datasets and develop a validation procedure for the identified method. The study finds that the traditional 2×2 grid approach can be misleading, indicating the need for a more reliable method. Using indirect (e.g., multiple regression) methods for determining importances may also be misleading.

Abstract

Several different approaches have been used to undertake Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA), aka quadrant analysis or gap analysis. This study compares methods across 15 datasets and finds that the traditional 2x2 grid approach can be misleading. Using indirect (e.g. multiple regression) methods for determining importances may also be misleading. The most valid method of performing IPA is identified, and a method for confirming its validity is provided.

References

22