Arrow@dit (Dublin Institute of Technology) · 2020 · 12 citations · 22 references
Open access
HumanitiesEmergency PreparednessTranslation StudiesReading ComprehensionTechnical TranslationTranslation TheoryMachine TranslationMachine Translation Post-editingSource Text AnalysisTranslation EditingTranslation Quality AssessmentTranslation ReceptionCognitive Effort In Post-editingPost-editingTranslation Quality Post-editing AssessmentTranslation Quality Scoring
We conducted a survey to understand the impact of machine translation and postediting awareness on comprehension of and trust in messages disseminated to prepare the public for a weather-related crisis, i.e. flooding. The translation direction was English–Italian. Sixty-one participants—all native Italian speakers with different English proficiency levels— answered our survey. Each participant read and evaluated between three and six crisis messages using ratings and openended questions on comprehensibility and trust. The messages were in English\nand Italian. All the Italian messages had been machine translated and post-edited.\nNevertheless, participants were told that only half had been post-edited, so that we could test the impact of post-editing awareness. We could not draw firm conclusions when comparing the scores for trust and comprehensibility assigned to the three types of messages—English,\npost-edits, and purported raw outputs.\nHowever, when scores were triangulated with open-ended answers, stronger patterns were observed, such as the impact of fluency of the translations on their comprehensibility and trustworthiness.\nWe found correlations between comprehensibility and trustworthiness, and identified other factors influencing these aspects, such as the clarity and soundness of the messages. We conclude by outlining implications for crisis preparedness, limitations, and areas for future research.
22
Attaining the Unattainable? Reassessing Claims of Human Parity in Neural Machine Translation
Antonio Toral, Sheila Castilho, Ke Hu et al. · 2018 · 202 citations · Full text