The Soed 'Competence' Guidelines for Initial Teacher Training: Issues of Control, Performance and Relevance

Ian Stronach, Bill Inglis, Jim McNally

Scottish Educational Review · 1994 · 14 citations · 4 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The SOED 'Competence' Guidelines for Initial Teacher Training have been the subject of recent controversy.They raise both specific and general issues of interpretation, as well as practical issues concerning the validity and utility of such lists.This article locates the Guidelines, and the more general debate about competence-based approaches to professionalism, within three different prespectives.The first is a critique of 'socially disembedded' knowledge.The second contrasts that critique with an account of the 'socially embodied' nature of competence construction.The third perspective evaluates the Guidelines in terms of empirical data on the school-based experiences of beginning teachers in Scotland, and finds both the 'competences' and some of their interpretations curiously detached from the realities they claim to address.

References

4