The effects of perceived anonymity and anonymity states on conformity and groupthink in online communities: A <scp>W</scp>ikipedia study

Michail Tsikerdekis

Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology · 2013 · 60 citations · 67 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Groupthink and conformity pose risks in online communities, especially when alternative solutions are overlooked, and while anonymity is known to influence conformity, prior studies have not examined how different anonymity states affect individuals’ likelihood to conform. The study surveyed random Wikipedia contributors to examine how anonymity influences the likelihood of conforming to group opinion. The survey distinguished between actual anonymity states and participants’ perceived anonymity to assess their impact on conformity. Results show that different anonymity states do not significantly affect conformity, leading the author to recommend design considerations for online community platforms.

Abstract

Groupthink behavior is always a risk in online groups and group decision support systems ( GDSS ), especially when not all potential alternatives for problem resolution are considered. It becomes a reality when individuals simply conform to the majority opinion and hesitate to suggest their own solutions to a problem. Anonymity has long been established to have an effect on conformity, but no previous research has explored the effects of different anonymity states in relation to an individual's likelihood to conform. Through a survey of randomly chosen participants from the E nglish‐language W ikipedia community, I explored the effects of anonymity on the likelihood of conforming to group opinion. In addition, I differentiated between actual states of anonymity and individuals' perceptions of anonymity. His findings indicate that although people perceive anonymity differently depending on their anonymity state, different states of anonymity do not have a strong effect on the likelihood of conforming to group opinion. Based on this evidence, I make recommendations for software engineers who have a direct hand in the design of online community platforms.

References

67