Cognitive Science · 2005 · 50 citations · 31 references
EducationEducational PsychologyInstructionMetacognitionMotor LearningReading ComprehensionLearner StrategiesSequence LearningSkill AcquisitionTransfer Of LearningAccuracyGeneralization Of Learned BehaviorGeneralization Of LearningLearningParametric VariationsProcedural KnowledgeSkill GeneralizationStrategy Transfer
Learning theories posit few mechanisms, yet individuals can master tasks through distinct paths such as instruction or practice. The study tests whether knowledge acquired via instruction versus practice differs in abstraction level and declarative/procedural balance. Participants learned patterned letter sequences either by direct instruction or by practicing extrapolation problems in a laboratory experiment. Both paths achieved mastery, but instruction produced more variable strategies and longer solution times, indicating distinct knowledge representations with implications for transfer and generalization.
Contemporary theories of learning postulate one or at most a small number of different learning mechanisms. However, people are capable of mastering a given task through qualitatively different learning paths such as learning by instruction and learning by doing. We hypothesize that the knowledge acquired through such alternative paths differs with respect to the level of abstraction and the balance between declarative and procedural knowledge. In a laboratory experiment we investigated what was learned about patterned letter sequences via either direct instruction in the relevant patterns or practice in solving letter-sequence extrapolation problems. Results showed that both types of learning led to mastery of the target task as measured by accuracy performance. However, behavioral differences emerged in how participants applied their knowledge. Participants given instruction showed more variability in the types of strategies they used to articulate their knowledge as well as longer solution times for generating the action implications of that knowledge as compared to the participants given practice. Results are discussed regarding the implications for transfer, generalization, and procedural application. Learning theories that claim generality should be tested against cross-scenario phenomena, not just parametric variations of a single learning scenario.
31
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
Keith E. Muller, Jacob Cohen · Technometrics · 1989 · 83.9K citations
Nick Axten, Allen Newell, Herbert A. Simon · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 1973 · 6.9K citations
Acquisition of cognitive skill.
John R. Anderson · Psychological Review · 1982 · 3.5K citations
Social Sciences, Educational Psychology, Cognitive Development +15
Jonathan Cohen, Brian MacWhinney, Matthew Flatt et al. · Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers · 1993 · 2.8K citations · Full text
The transfer of cognitive skill
Choice Reviews Online · 1990 · 1.3K citations