Use of Top-Level Structure in Text: Key for Reading Comprehension of Ninth-Grade Students

Bonnie J. F. Meyer, David M. Brandt, George J. Bluth

Reading Research Quarterly · 1980 · 702 citations · 20 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study situates the structure strategy within its developmental trajectory across ages and discourse types. The study examined how ninth‑grade students employ a structure‑based reading strategy, hypothesizing that signaling would interact with mastery, with good comprehenders using the strategy regardless of signaling, poor comprehenders not using it, and underachievers using it only when signaling was present. The experiment used well‑organized problem/solution or comparison texts with varied signaling to alter structural saliency, and also examined the reading and retelling approaches of students who did not employ the structure strategy. Most predictions were supported, showing that the structure strategy functions as an effective retrieval mnemonic.

Abstract

THE STUDY INVESTIGATES ninth-grade students' use of a reading strategy (the structure strategy) which focuses on following the organizational structure of text in order to determine what is important to remember. Texts read were well organized with problem/solution or comparison structures; signaling varied the saliency of these structures. Signaling effects were expected to interact with mastery of the structure strategy. Regardless of signaling, good comprehenders on the Stanford Achievement Test were expected to follow the structure strategy while poor comprehenders were not. However, comprehension underachievers (vocabulary substantially above comprehension test scores) were expected to follow the structure strategy only when signaling was present. Most predictions were supported; the structure strategy appeared to be a particularly effective retrieval mneumonic. Its development with age across different discourse types is discussed. Also characterized is the approach to reading and retelling of ninthgrade students who do not employ this structure strategy.

References

20