Promoting reflective information literacy practice through Facilitating Information Literacy Education (FILE)

Susie Andretta

Health Information & Libraries Journal · 2008 · 11 citations · 1 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

A systematic review1 recently published in this journal focuses on the topic of reflection. As the author, Maria Grant, states, ‘Reflection on practice can be a process through which individual learning can be achieved, and personal and professional knowledge can be acquired ...’1 p.164 Reflection can also be a method of evaluation and form part of evidence-based practice, as suggested by Booth.2 p.130 In previous articles in this feature, we have discussed the value of action research and how this can help us to reflect on our practice as trainers and educators. In the following article, Susie Andretta demonstrates how the adoption of reflective practice in a professional development course to facilitate information literacy practices has added value for the participants, not only during the course, but also in the long term. Margaret E. S. Forrest Susie Andretta School of Information Management, London Metropolitan University, UK The course was commissioned in 2006 by London Health Libraries3 to train National Health Service (NHS) librarians in information literacy education as part of their Learner Support Programme. The course is run by the School of Information Management at London Metropolitan University and aims to develop the competence and confidence needed to facilitate information literacy practices in support of diverse populations of users. FILE is a hybrid course delivering a continuing professional development (CPD) programme within formally approved postgraduate provision. FILE transcends the aims of a traditional training course on learning and teaching, or on developing the users’ information skills by focusing on the complex relationship between the learner and information literacy, and by exploring ways of facilitating such a relationship to enhance the quality of the learning experience. A full account of the course and the experience of the 2007 cohort goes beyond the scope of this article and is given elsewhere.4–6 Here, we examine how this course fosters professional development through reflective practice by looking at the first assessed component of FILE on the 2008 cohort.7 Reflective practice is mapped onto the fourth learning outcome of FILE, which states that the course helps the participants to: ‘reflect on the process and the impact of information literacy practice on their professional development’. Component 1 fosters the participants’ reflection on the following aspects: Their initial expectations of FILE which are contextualized within their current training experience. The profiles of the users they are currently supporting (including an assessment of the users information needs and level of information literacy competences). Their definitions of effective learning and how these views inform their information literacy practice. By focusing on their initial expectations of FILE, the participants identify the areas of information literacy education that they aim to develop or consolidate. The participants’ CPD targets are necessarily linked to the information literacy profiles of the users they support and highlight the challenges brought about by user diversity, while the articulation of effective learning strategies helps them see the connection between these and their information literacy practice. In this section we examine four main themes generated by the targets set by the participants for Component 1 and, as alluded to earlier, the data cited here are taken from the 2008 FILE cohort.8 The majority of the comments show that, despite coming to FILE with considerable training experience, the participants have not undergone ‘formal training’ that ‘specifically looks at [...] how people learn and methods to make training effective and relevant to the end-user.’, or covers ‘training specifically on education in relation to information literacy’. In some cases, the absence of a recognized ‘educator’ status leads to an unjustified lack of professional esteem where despite ‘several years of training experience’ some participants do not consider themselves ‘expert’ trainers. This view parallels the one expressed by a health librarian who completed an online survey9 conducted by the author of this article. This survey aimed to explore whether health librarians define their professional role as information provider or as information literacy educator.10 The quote presented here illustrates the paradox of not being qualified to call themselves educators, although in practice educating users is part of their professional responsibilities: ‘I was warned by someone at the MLA conference against using the term IL educator until I had gained a recognized teaching qualification. I am therefore careful not to use that term although this certainly describes some of my activities.’11 Variation in the users’ profile occurs at a number of levels. In some cases, the participants describe their training role as divided into higher education (HE) and NHS environments leading to ‘a great diversity of users and situations’. The diverse profiles of these two groups generate different levels of motivation in the users which lead to different levels of engagement with the training: ‘while students have assessments and exams monitoring their skills, it may be less clear to NHS how their day-to-day work will be affected by information literacy skills training.’ In response to this, some participants make a point of stressing that the ultimate goal of the training is to go beyond CPD and academic learning in order to ‘underpin clinical audit and governance and support clinical decisions about patient care.’ User diversity is clearly one of the main challenges faced by information literacy educators operating in the health sector. Another FILE participant illustrates just how complex this issue is: ‘As a trainer, I face a wide range of users, from those with few library or study skills, and little experience or confidence in IT (possibly domestic staff) to those with extensive experience in IT and a great deal of confidence in its use (consultants, etc.) and everywhere on the spectrum between these extremes.’ In addition, location of training and mode of delivery vary depending on which group of users the participants are supporting at any given time: ‘Group sizes also vary—anything from one-to-one training to groups of 14–16. Location of training also varies and is carried out either in an NHS library setting or at the learner's workplace.’ Effective learning is primarily summarized as a ‘hands-on’ experience or as explained by one participant: ‘we learn by “doing” as opposed to merely “hearing”.’ A number of features characterize this approach identifying the areas an information literacy educator must adopt, such as employing customized delivery to suit the diverse learning styles and competences of the users. One participant explains the need for customization very clearly: ‘everyone works a little differently. An awareness of this is vital to support users effectively and I try to consciously tailor my sessions to the individual [...]’. The fact that each user learns differently is further articulated by another participant who argues that learning is effective when: ‘[...] the content is relevant, [the] exercises are suitable and pitched at the correct level for the users, and supporting materials can be used independently after the course [where appropriate] support [is provided] for those that need extra help, but not ignoring those who don't.’ Some participants emphasize the importance of establishing a safe environment for learning (and information literacy education) to be effective: ‘The approachability of the trainer, the level of delivery, the training documentation are key to ensuring that the learner feels comfortable, at ease, ready and able to learn.’ Some participants propose a supportive Community of Practice (CoP) as a way of furthering a well-established training role: ‘Although experienced in information skills training for a diverse group of health care professionals in both acute and primary care, to be more effective as an information literacy facilitator I believe I need the peer group support FILE would provide. The opportunity to interact, observe and study together with fellow trainers would be invaluable.’ We now turn to the analysis of the participants’ own reflections of the impact of Component 1 drawn from the written responses they gave when prompted to evaluate the relevance of this experience to their information literacy practice. Overall, the participants claim that the intended outcome of Component 1 was successfully achieved: ‘The exercise enabled me to identify my learning needs and motivation for being on this course.’ Not surprisingly, the identification of measurable CPD targets highlights the areas that need to be worked on, such as not taking credit for the competence in information literacy the participants already possess: ‘[...] Component 1 [...] was also useful in informing and sharing with my colleagues at what point I thought I was in my development. The hardest bit I found was writing [about] my strengths; I was too modest.’ In addition, writing down their reflections within a tight word limit (300 words) is seen as both a challenge, because of the limited scope for elaborating on the main issues, and as a benefit in that it helps to crystallize ideas and prioritize the main points. Other benefits cited include becoming more aware of user diversity and of the need to develop information literacy strategies that address this: ‘[Component 1] was very useful as it made me think carefully about my users, what they want and how best to provide this—especially given that there are potentially 2000 very different ones of them and only one of me!’ Some participants also comment on the positive impact of applying their personal view of effective learning on their own training practice. This makes them experience learning in terms of their progression through FILE and in terms of the impact of this on their current and future information literacy practice. This article has given a brief account of how the adoption of a reflective practice promoted by FILE offers a number of benefits for librarians who operate as information literacy educators within the health sector. First of all, this approach enables them to gauge the development of their information literacy practice. Secondly, it encourages them to customize information literacy provision to suit the diverse populations of users, while at the same time promoting a supportive and safe learning environment. The reflections generated by Component 1 are revisited at the end of FILE with Component 5 (in May) when the participants produce an overall evaluation of the impact of this course. This in turn informs future CPD targets. The examples given here present the initial cycle of reflective practice which starts with the identification of the CPD targets in relation to information literacy education and ends with an evaluation of the fulfilment of these targets on completion of the course. Reflective practice does not end with FILE. The testimony of a participant from the 2007 cohort shows that such practice continues to inform the professional development beyond the confines of the course: ‘The course went over and above my expectations. The bonding of the group, the enthusiasm of the course leader and the interesting and challenging tasks were a memorable and unique experience that I have already been able to draw on and will continue to do so.’12 My thanks go to the current FILE participants who have given me the permission to cite their work in this article.

References

1