Using concept maps to assess student learning in the science classroom: Must different methods compete?

Diana C. Rice, Joseph M. Ryan, Sara M. Samson

Journal of Research in Science Teaching · 1998 · 172 citations · 24 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Concept map scoring methods that emphasize correctness of propositions differ from traditional hierarchy‑based approaches, and prior research shows they effectively assess higher‑level learning outcomes. The study aimed to develop a scoring method for concept maps that evaluates students’ knowledge and comprehension in science. Implemented over a year in seventh‑grade life science classes, the teacher‑researcher linked concept‑map scoring to instructional objectives, assigning points based on proposition correctness. Concept‑map scores correlated strongly with unit multiple‑choice tests, state criterion‑referenced, and national norm‑referenced standardized tests, demonstrating content and concurrent validity and showing that both declarative and procedural knowledge can be assessed without dichotomizing curriculum and assessment. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc., J Res Sci Teach 35:1103–1127.

Abstract

This yearlong study was implemented in seventh-grade life science classes with the students' regular teacher serving as teacher/researcher. In the study, a method of scoring concept maps was developed to assess knowledge and comprehension levels of science achievement. By linking scoring of concept maps to instructional objectives, scores were based upon the correctness of propositions. High correlations between the concept map scores and unit multiple choice tests provided strong evidence of the content validity of the map scores. Similarly, correlations between map scores and state criterion-referenced and national norm-referenced standardized tests were indicators of high concurrent validity. The approach to concept map scoring in the study represents a distinct departure from traditional methods that focus on characteristics such as hierarchy and branching. A large body of research has demonstrated the utility of such methods in the assessment of higher-level learning outcomes. The results of the study suggest that a concept map might be used in assessing declarative and procedural knowledge, both of which have a place in the science classroom. One important implication of these results is that science curriculum and its corresponding assessment need not be dichotomized into knowledge/comprehension versus higher-order outcomes. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 35: 1103–1127, 1998.

References

24