Academic advising: does it really impact student success?

Adena Young-Jones, Tracie D. Burt, Stephanie Dixon, Melissa J. Hawthorne

Quality Assurance in Education · 2013 · 209 citations · 23 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study evaluates academic advising by focusing on student needs, expectations, and success rather than satisfaction. The study surveyed 611 students and applied factor analysis, regression, and ANOVA to examine advising experiences. Six factors—advisor accountability, empowerment, student responsibility, self‑efficacy, study skills, and perceived support—were linked to success, with demographic differences indicating the need for targeted advising improvements.

Abstract

Purpose This study was designed to evaluate academic advising in terms of student needs, expectations, and success rather than through the traditional lens of student satisfaction with the process. Design/methodology/approach Student participants ( n =611) completed a survey exploring their expectations of and experience with academic advising. Principal axis factor analysis, multiple regression analyses, and analyses of variance were applied to student responses. Findings Six interpretable factors (i.e. advisor accountability, advisor empowerment, student responsibility, student self‐efficacy, student study skills, and perceived support) significantly related academic advising to student success. Differences emerged with regard to advisement of demographically diverse students. Practical implications The results suggest improvements in advising practices, particularly interventions focused on specific demographic populations. Originality/value The present study contributes to existing literature by expanding advising research beyond student satisfaction to explore how it influences student success. Additionally, results suggest a need for future research that further develops the concept and practice of quality academic advising.

References

23