Journal of Research in Childhood Education · 2000 · 20 citations · 20 references
EducationEducational AssessmentEducational MeasurementChild DevelopmentClassroom AssessmentPerformance AssessmentAbility GroupingAchievement TestingEthnicity In EducationEthnicity In SchoolingGender DifferencesStudent Achievement AnalysisAchievement MeasurementComparative Achievement AnalysisGender Differences In AchievementMain EffectsMathematics Achievement GapsSelection Bias AnalysisStudent Achievement EvidenceWriting Achievement
Abstract This study compared reading, writing, and mathematics achievement of students in comparable multiage and single-age classrooms in three different school districts. We sought links between these two types of classroom groupings and 1) gender, 2) Title I and non-Title I status, and 3) Hispanic and non-Hispanic students. We used performance-based standardized achievement tests to assess student abilities of a more complex nature. This study used samples of 3rd-graders from school districts where both single-age and multiage classrooms existed. One threat to the validity of these results was selection bias (Burns & Mason, 1998). This threat was taken into consideration by using a control variable, Title I and non-Title I. We analyzed results by main effects and interaction with this control variable to determine if the type of student taught (e.g., Title I or non-Title I; boy or girl) seemed affected by classroom organization. Results showed higher achievement for regular students in multiage settings when compared with the same population of students in a single-age setting, but no differences were observed for Title I students in both multiage and single-age settings. We concluded that non-Title I students in multiage classrooms were achieving more highly than non-Title I students in comparable traditional single-age settings. However, the hypothesis that multiage grouping might benefit Title I students and other traditionally lower-achieving students was not borne out in this descriptive study.
20