Journal of Language and Social Psychology · 2005 · 169 citations · 28 references
Social SciencesCommunicationPsychologyCommunication TheoryPersuasionSocial InfluenceArgumentationElaboration LikelihoodResistance To PersuasionRhetorical AppealsSocial JudgmentComprehensive ExamsComprehensive Final ExamsDepth Of ProcessingLinguistic Features Of ArgumentationPersuasive Arguments TheoryPersuasive LanguageTag QuestionsVerbal Persuasion
This research examined the unique effects of different markers of linguistic powerlessness (hedges, hesitations, and tag questions) on persuasion. Participants read (Experiment 1) or listened to (Experiment 2) a communication advocating comprehensive exams. Under high message relevance, messages containing powerless markers resulted in less favorable attitudes and more negative perceptions of the message and source than did the control message. This effect occurred in both experiments and was a result of these markers lessening the impact of strong arguments; in Experiment 2, strong arguments were no more persuasive than weak arguments when the message contained any of these markers. Under low message relevance, tag questions improved the persuasiveness of message arguments relative to the control condition. These results demonstrate that the effects of linguistic markers of powerlessness are complex and depend on marker type and processing depth.
28
Ann Scott, Robin Tolmach Lakoff · The English Journal · 1976 · 1.4K citations
Gender, language, and influence.
Linda L. Carli · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · 1990 · 614 citations