Fitness for Purpose? National and Institutional Approaches to Publicising the Student Voice

James Williams, Gill Cappuccini‐Ansfield

Quality in Higher Education · 2007 · 94 citations · 11 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Collecting student feedback is a key quality pillar, yet many surveys exist whose suitability for purpose remains unclear, especially when contrasting the UK’s National Student Survey—targeted at prospective students and accountability—with the Student Satisfaction Approach, which primarily informs internal improvement. This study compares the fitness for purpose of a nationwide survey with that of a tailor‑made institutional survey. The two surveys differ markedly in content and presentation, and their results are not interchangeable.

Abstract

Abstract Collecting feedback from students on their experiences of higher education has become one of the central pillars of the quality process. Many surveys are being carried out but it is not always clear how fit for purpose they are. This paper compares the fitness for purpose of a nation‐wide survey and a tailor‐made institutional survey. The National Student Survey, recently introduced in the UK, aims to provide information for prospective students and address public accountability, whereas the Student Satisfaction Approach is designed primarily to inform internal quality improvement processes but also to supply some information to prospective students. The two surveys are also very different in content and presentation of results. The two surveys are not interchangeable in use.

References

11