Extracurricular School Activities: The Good, the Bad, and the Nonlinear

Herbert W. Marsh, Sabina Kleitman

Harvard Educational Review · 2002 · 502 citations · 47 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The authors investigate how participation in extracurricular school activities influences grade‑twelve performance and postsecondary outcomes such as academic achievement, career aspirations, and substance‑abuse avoidance. Their analysis employs three theoretical frameworks—the threshold, identification/commitment, and social‑inequality‑gap‑reduction models—to interpret the impact of ESAs. They find that ESAs produce modest, nonlinear benefits with diminishing returns at very high participation, that school‑based activities are more advantageous than out‑of‑school ones, that both academic and nonacademic ESAs are most effective, and that socioeconomically disadvantaged students gain as much or more, supporting the view that ESAs enhance school identification and commitment to improve diverse academic outcomes.

Abstract

In this article, Herbert W. Marsh and Sabina Kleitman examine the effects of participation in extracurricular school activities (ESAs) on grade-twelve and postsecondary outcomes (e.g., school grades, coursework selection, homework, educational and occupational aspirations, self-esteem, freedom from substance abuse,number of university applications, subsequent college enrollment, and highest educational level). Their analyses are grounded in three theoretical models: the threshold model, the identification/commitment model, and the social inequality gap reduction model. They find that, consistent with the threshold model predictions, there were some small nonlinear ESA effects — monotonic increases over most of the ESA range, but diminishing returns for extremely high levels of ESA. Consistent with identification/commitment model predictions, school-based ESAs were more beneficial than out-of-school activities, and the most beneficial ESAs included both nonacademic(sports, student government, school publications, and performing arts)and academic activities. Finally, consistent with the social inequality gap reduction model predictions (as well as the identification/commitment model), ESAs benefited socioeconomically disadvantaged students as much or more than advantaged students. In summary, the authors' findings support the conclusion that ESAs foster school identification/commitment that benefits diverse academic outcomes, particularly for socioeconomically disadvantaged students who are least well served by the traditional educational curriculum.

References

47