2011 · 29 citations · 6 references
EducationTeacher EducationTeachingClassroom AssessmentLesson PlanningPedagogyClassroom Assessment PracticesInstructional DeliveryTeacher Capacity BuildingTeacher Preparation PolicyTeacher Professional DevelopmentEducational TheoryLesson Planning ModelsPre-service Teacher EducationRetention Of Novice TeachersTeacher Development Plans
The increased accountability brought about by NCLB, in conjunction with expected nationwide teacher shortages has left many districts in dire need of skillful teachers (Lambert, 2006). Looking to recent college graduates to fill this need, colleges of education are left searching for the best way to prepare their future teachers. Such demands require that teachers are able to create lessons grounded in current learning theory. New teachers must have an eye for assessment and infuse active learning in all that they do. In their preparation, teacher education graduates have undoubtedly been exposed to a magnitude of educational theory supporting these endeavors. However novice teachers historically struggle in incorporating these ideas into their daily lessons. Caught up in the demands of being a first year teachers, novices can quickly lose sight of these ideals and may begin to find themselves unable to bridge the gap between their university studies and daily practice. Puzzled by this reality, this study is the result of three years of research and data collection on novice teacher lesson planning and delivery. Information was gathered in a co-taught teacher education classroom where a professor and two practicing secondary educators shared teaching responsibilities. Nearly 500 pieces of teaching were used to extrapolate common pitfalls of lesson planning and their effects on teacher effectiveness. Moreover, this study was extended to include the lesson planning problems of first and second year teachers- a smaller sample of recent graduates. We sought to investigate the following research questions: (1) Do practicing teachers and pre-service teachers make similar lesson planning mistakes? (2) What can teacher educators do so that pre-service teachers do not repeatedly make the same lesson planning mistakes? Our study addresses these questions. Methods Pre-service teachers in our study participated in these micro-teachings throughout the course of the semester which required each pre-service teacher to plan and teach a lesson about an assigned topic to 3-5 of their peers. The co-teaching structure of this course allowed us to observe and participate in the pre service teachers' lessons. In sitting through many of these teachings, over six semesters, we specifically looked for those moments of disengagement, discontinuity or ambiguity in lesson delivery. We also paid special attention to when general confusion developed among the participants in the base group. Some of these lessons were video recorded for further analysis, and both verbal and written reflection data was collected. Common mistakes that were observed by the three co-teachers independently were then synthesized into an initial set of lesson planning 'blunders' which we looked for when the pre service teachers taught again that semester, and in the subsequent semesters. After discerning the six most common and detrimental pre-service lesson planning pitfalls, we compared our findings to the lesson planning difficulties of teachers at different stages in their teaching careers. Throughout the course of monthly professional learning community meetings, we interviewed student teachers, to see if any of the lesson planning issues they mentioned were analogous to those we noticed with our pre-service teachers. We then interviewed a small sample of first and second year teachers (who did not go through our teacher education program) to discuss issues they have when planning learning experiences for their students. Once again, we looked for commonalities to confirm our hypotheses. In compiling all that we discovered from this observational and interview data, we identified generalizable assertions that are presented in the results section below. Results The results presented in this paper are the six most common lesson planning 'blunders' that were noted in our novice teacher study. These results were generalized based on the responses of our pre-service, first and second year teachers. …
6