Design Science · 2021 · 34 citations · 132 references
ArtsDesignCognitive PsychologyCreative Problem SolvingDesign ThinkingCognitive AbilitiesDivergent ThinkingCognitive FlexibilityConcept GenerationConvergent Thinking StyleDesign Thinking ProcessEngineering Design ThinkingFirst-generation StudentsSustainability In Engineering EducationUncertainty Processing
Abstract The research presented in this paper explores how engineering students cognitively manage concept generation and measures the effects of additional dimensions of sustainability on design cognition. Twelve first-year and eight senior engineering students generated solutions to 10 design problems. Half of the problems included additional dimensions of sustainability. The number of unique design solutions students developed and their neurocognitive activation were measured. Without additional requirements for sustainability, first-year students generated significantly more solutions than senior engineering students. First-year students recruited higher cortical activation in the brain region generally associated with cognitive flexibility, and divergent and convergent thinking. Senior engineering students recruited higher activation in the brain region generally associated with uncertainty processing and self-reflection. When additional dimensions of sustainability were present, first-year students produced fewer solutions. Senior engineering students generated a similar number of solutions. Senior engineering students required less cortical activation to generate a similar number of solutions. The varying patterns of cortical activation and different number of solutions between first-year and senior engineering students begin to highlight cognitive differences in how students manage and retrieve information in their brain during design. Students’ ability to manage complex requirements like sustainability may improve with education.
132
Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data
M. Venkatesan, K. Anders Ericsson, Herbert A. Simon · Journal of Marketing Research · 1986 · 4.4K citations
Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach
Students Quarterly Journal · 1963 · 4.1K citations · Full text
Arts, Design, Systems Engineering +12
Engineering Design Thinking, Teaching, and Learning
Clive L. Dym, Alice M. Agogino, Özgür Eriş et al. · Journal of Engineering Education · 2005 · 2.7K citations
Arts, Design, Electrical Engineering +13