Marketing Science · 2018 · 40 citations · 65 references
BusinessAccountancyAccountingFinancial AccountingFinancial EconomicsManagerial AccountingAsset AccountingEquity AccountingFinancial ReportingFinancial StatementsDepreciated Replacement CostFirm Financial PerformanceMarket Performance MetricsReplacement Cost ApproachStrategic Performance Reporting
Accounting-based approximations of Tobin’s q (AATQ) are increasingly popular in marketing. AATQ differ from Tobin’s original conception in that they use accounting data to assess the replacement cost of a firm’s assets; the core problem with this is that valuable assets go unrecorded in external reports, including systematic underrecording of market-based assets. This research examines the extensive erroneous claims made about AATQ in marketing studies. We note the widespread use of the metrics and demonstrate that the AATQ used in marketing (1) are not comparable across industries, (2) do not use only tangible assets in their denominator, and (3) should not find equilibrium at 1. AATQ are often described as performance metrics and can respond appropriately to certain types of positive performance. Unfortunately, they also respond positively to performance-neutral strategic choices. Furthermore, whenever AATQ exceed 1, as is typical, they increase even with completely wasted investments. We note that AATQ are especially problematic measures of performance for marketers because they are biased toward reporting that investments in market-based assets (e.g., brand equity and customer satisfaction) are effective. The misuse of AATQ we document suggests the need for marketing scholars to pay greater attention to the theoretical underpinnings of their metrics.
65
A General Equilibrium Approach To Monetary Theory
James Tobin · Journal of money credit and banking · 1969 · 5.3K citations
Diversification's effect on firm value
Philip G. Berger, Eli Ofek · Journal of Financial Economics · 1995 · 3.2K citations · Full text
Intangibles: Management, Measurement, and Reporting
Chris Higson · The International Journal of Accounting · 2001 · 1.5K citations
Business, Accountancy, Accounting +10