Nutrient based functional unit for meals

Thomas Kägi, Mischa Zschokke, Fredy Dinkel

2015 · 11 citations · 2 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The goal of this study was to compare the environmental impact of meals and their ingredients and to analyse the influence of the functional unit on the results. For this study all relevant life cycle phases were considered. The functional units we compared: 1 meal (about 450g); adjusted by the nutrient density score (NDS); adjusted by the nutrient rich food index (NRF9.3). A comparison of the different meals per plate or adjusted by the NRF9.3 method shows that the most relevant impact comes from meat. If the results are weighted by the NDS method, beef still shows a high impact but is not as dominant due to its high nutrient density. Using this method whether the ingredients are regionally or seasonally produced becomes much more relevant. Taking the uncertainty into account a meal with vegetables out of season can but must not have a significant lower environmental impact than a meat meal. The different outcomes due to the three different functional units used show the importance to take into account the adequate circumstances when defining the functional unit. What is adequate to compare - the amount of food, the nutritional value of food or the nutritional health of food? Otherwise, the functional unit and the results may not answer the questions.

References

2