The Reading Teacher · 1967 · 120 citations · 3 references
EducationElementary EducationLiteracy EducationReading ComprehensionReading DevelopmentReading EducationCritical ReadingReadingReading AssessmentReading InstructionAssessmentsLiteral ReadingStandardized Reading Tests
in 1917, THORNDiKE outlined a classic definition of reading in three words when he said, Reading is thinking. Fifty years later, the con versation on the reading scene is still concerned with reading as thinking with regard to how varied reading-thinking can be developed with in the classroom. Despite the numerous treatments of such reading thinking as critical reading skills in the professional press, con tentions abound that classroom teachers are doing little to develop a variety of reading-thinking skills. Rather, according to Austin and Mor rison (1964) and Henry (1963), teachers appear to equate reading thinking with the most narrow of literal comprehension skills. Because standardized reading tests tend to measure literal compre hension skills, it is difficult to make wide assessments of pupils' abilities in various reading-thinking areas. In the absence of such test results, it seems advisable to examine the interaction between teachers and stu dents in the reading circle as they engage in the development of read thinking skills. Thus, the current study was initiated in an effort to make determinations about the state of reading-thinking development as it occurred in the context of the reading group in the elementary grades. Observation and study were guided by the following questions: /. What kinds of thinking questions do teachers ask about reading as signments in selected second, fourth, and sixth grade classrooms? In what frequencies do the various question types occur? 2. How frequently are teacher questions about reading assignments met with congruent or correct student responses? 3. Do teachers employ certain questioning strategies as they question students about reading assignments? If so, what are the characteristics of these strategies?
3