Medical Teacher · 2012 · 65 citations · 25 references
EducationEducational AssessmentMedical EducationAssessment DesignClinical MedicineResidency TrainingFeedback For LearningFeedback In AssessmentFeedback PracticesSupervision ProcessTeacher EvaluationWorkplace Learning EvaluationAssessment Of Professional SkillsClinical Skills TrainingClinical TeachingContent Validity AssessmentContent Validity EvidenceFeedback In Clinical AssessmentFeedback In Clinical TrainingSupervisory Feedback Quality
BACKGROUND: Providing clinical teachers in postgraduate medical education with feedback about their teaching skills is a powerful tool to improve clinical teaching. A systematic review showed that available instruments do not comprehensively cover all domains of clinical teaching. We developed and empirically test a comprehensive instrument for assessing clinical teachers in the setting of workplace learning and linked to the CanMEDS roles. METHODS: In a Delphi study, the content validity of a preliminary instrument with 88 items was studied, leading to the construction of the EFFECT (evaluation and feedback for effective clinical teaching) instrument. The response process was explored in a pilot test and focus group research with 18 residents of 6 different disciplines. A confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) and reliability analyses were performed on 407 evaluations of 117 supervisors, collected in 3 medical disciplines (paediatrics, pulmonary diseases and surgery) of 6 departments in 4 different hospitals. RESULTS: CFA yielded an 11 factor model with a good to excellent fit and internal consistencies ranged from 0.740 to 0.940 per domain; 7 items could be deleted. CONCLUSION: The model of workplace learning showed to be a useful framework for developing EFFECT, which incorporates the CanMEDS competencies and proved to be valid and reliable.
25
Alternative Ways of Assessing Model Fit
Michael W. Browne, Robert Cudeck · Sociological Methods & Research · 1992 · 25.2K citations
Comparative fit indexes in structural models.
Peter M. Bentler · Psychological Bulletin · 1990 · 23.9K citations
John Hattie, Helen Timperley · Review of Educational Research · 2007 · 12.1K citations · Full text