Can computer‐aided instruction accommodate all learners equally?

Jonathan L. Ross, Robert Schulz

British Journal of Educational Technology · 1999 · 96 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study explored how learning styles influence human‑computer interaction. Seventy learners from a large urban postsecondary institution were assessed using the Gregorc Style Delineator to determine their dominant learning styles. Results showed no significant differences in learning indices by style, yet learning styles significantly impacted outcomes, indicating that certain learners—especially Abstract Random types—may struggle with computer‑aided instruction, suggesting it is not universally effective.

Abstract

This exploratory study investigated the impact of learning styles on human‐computer interaction. Seventy learners who were enrolled in a large urban post‐secondary institution participated in the study. The Gregorc Style Delineator™ was used to obtain subjects' dominant learning style scores. Results indicated that patterns of learning indices did not differ significantly based on subjects' dominant learning style. Five of the six measures indicating human‐computer interaction behavior were not significant at the p < 0.05 level. However, learning styles significantly affected learning outcomes, as indicated by a significant main effect, as well as an interaction effect between dominant learning style and achievement scores. It would appear that Abstract Random learners may be at‐risk for doing poorly with certain forms of computer‐aided instruction. Based on the review of literature and results found in this study, it was concluded that computer‐aided instruction may not be the most appropriate method of learning for all students.