Journal of Experimental Psychology General · 2008 · 24 citations · 54 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyIndividual DifferencesSocial ComparisonVisual AttentionBiasImpression FormationOpinion ComparisonProbability JudgmentSocial JudgmentAbove-average EffectBetter-than-average EffectBiasesCognitive Bias In EvaluationComparative Judgment BiasDecision BiasesReferent InfluenceSubjective Probability Judgments
Above-average and below-average effects appear to be common and consistent across a variety of judgment domains. For example, several studies show that individual items from a high- (low-) quality set tend to be rated as better (worse) than the other items in the set (e.g., E. E. Giladi & Y. Klar, 2002). Experiments in this article demonstrate reversals of these effects. A novel account is supported, which describes how the timing of the denotation of the to-be-judged item influences attention and ultimately affects the size or direction of comparative biases. The authors discuss how this timing account is relevant for many types of referent-dependent judgments (e.g., probability judgments, resource allocations) and how it intersects with various accounts of comparative bias (focalism, generalized-group, compromise between local and general standards [LOGE]).
54
Amos Tversky · Psychological Review · 1977 · 7.3K citations
Steven J. Spencer, Mark P. Zanna, Geoffrey T. Fong · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · 2005 · 2.4K citations
Support theory: A nonextensional representation of subjective probability.
Amos Tversky, Derek J. Koehler · Psychological Review · 1994 · 1.2K citations
Business, Psychology, Surgery +16