The Commonality of Extreme Discrepancies in the Ability Profiles of Academically Gifted Students

David F. Lohman, James L. Gambrell, Joni M. Lakin

Psychology science · 2008 · 62 citations · 16 references

Concepts

Abstract

Extreme discrepancies in abilities are more common among the most and least able students than among average ability children. Therefore, procedures for identifying gifted children that deliberately or inadvertently rely on a composite score that averages across ability domains will exclude many children who reason exceptionally well in particular symbol systems. In this article, we first discuss general issues in the measurement of ability profiles. We then introduce a method for categorizing score profiles and finally document the reliability and stability of score profiles using the 2000 standardization data of the Cognitive Abilities Test (Lohman & Hagen, 2001a).

References

16