Gifted Child Quarterly · 1985 · 423 citations · 17 references
EducationEducational PsychologyCreativityGifted EducationIndividual DifferencesAbility ComparisonCharacteristics Of Gifted LearnersTalent DevelopmentTalent Development PsychologyTwice-exceptional StudentsUnderachievement In Gifted StudentsCauses Of UnderachievementGifted IndividualsGiftedness Identification
The literature lacks a clear distinction between giftedness and talent. The study reviews common definitions of giftedness and talent, focusing on Renzulli and Cohn models. The authors discuss motivation and environmental quality as catalysts for actualizing giftedness in specific talents. The critique distinguishes giftedness as domain‑specific abilities that foster exceptional performance, allowing one to be gifted without being talented, but not the reverse.
In the scientific literature, there is ambiguity in the distinction between the concepts of giftedness and talent. This paper examines several common definitions of these two terms, with particular emphasis on the models proposed by Renzulli (1979) and Cohn (1981). Our critique of these two models leads to a clear differentiation between giftedness and talent: the former is associated with domains of abilities which foster and explain exceptional performance in varied fields of activities, that is, talents. Thus, one can be gifted without necessarily being talented (as with the case of underachievers), but not vice versa. Several factors which can act as catalysts for the actualization of giftedness in specific talents are discussed, particularly motivation and environmental quality.
17
What Makes Giftedness?: Reexamining a Definition
Joseph S. Renzulli · Phi Delta Kappan · 2011 · 1.2K citations
Giftedness, Conflict, and Underachievement
G/C/T · 1983 · 562 citations
Student Evaluation of Instruction
Don Kunz, Kenneth O. Doyle, Jerry G. Gaff · AAUP Bulletin · 1977 · 144 citations