Two Feedback Types: Do They Make A Difference?

Ken Sheppard

RELC Journal · 1992 · 323 citations · 8 references

Concepts

Abstract

This study contrasts the effects of two distinct ways of respon ding to a student essay: discrete-item attention to form and holistic feedback on meaning. In examining the before- and after-essays of a linguistically diverse group of 26 college freshmen, it shows that the use of a holistic response is likely to increase a student's awareness of sentence boundaries more than the alternative. In other words, responding to content results in improvements in grammatical accu racy. General implications are also addressed.

References

8